I’m not a fan of Jeff Van Gundy — the only time he comes up in conversation is when I need someone to compare to Stevie from ‘Eastbound & Down’ — but I appreciate the thorough, somewhat obnoxious lengths he goes to to condemn flopping during Sunday’s game between the Miami Heat and New York Knicks. He’s right (he’s completely, 100% right), but at some point when he’s shouting over the upcoming games graphics you expect him to turn into Mike Gundy and scream about how old he is.
And no matter how right he is (he is totally right), the NBA isn’t going to punish flopping because you can’t punish flopping. Not only because of that terrible argument soccer fans use about it being “how the game is played”, but because if you start calling a technical on every guy on the court who doesn’t fall straight back when he’s touched you are swiftly and permanently neutering an honest man’s ability to play defense. Fines won’t work either, because LeBron James isn’t going to miss that 10-grand he’ll consciously decide to pay when he goes down like a fainting French lass at a f**king cotillion to regain possession in the playoffs.
It also won’t work because Jeff Van Gundy said it.
I guess the only way to fix it is a fundamental restructuring of sports and parenting, where we can organize teams in a world where people were raised with the idea that they should always try to do the right thing, and in a world where Winning At Sports isn’t a higher priority than decency. Also in this world, the Miami Heat have been put into a space shuttle and piloted into the sun.
[h/t to Ball Don't Lie]


When did Michael Cole start doing commentary for the NBA?
Go Heat.
I enjoyed the excessive use of the word “flopping”
I think, at the very least, they could whistle it more often than they do. Of course it’s a fine line between a legit reaction/a bit of melodramatic exaggeration and a total balls-out didn’t-even-touch-the-guy flop, but lots of penalties are called in that gray area. Hockey and football both have penalties for doing something similar (diving and unsportsmanlike conduct), but they’re rarely called; some of that may have to do with the constitutions of the sports themselves, but I’d bet that a lot of it has to do with the idea that, if you flop like a child at the playground wanting attention from his mommy, you will get caught and your team will be punished for it. You won’t flop too many more times once your coach pulls you aside after your team lets up a TD after a 15-yard penalty and a first down or a power play goal. Also you might get run into the boards by an opposing player pissed that you’re not playing the game right, there’s always that.
I agree that it’s impractical to punish flopping in the middle of a game, but there’s no reason not to retroactively punish guys after the game if obvious flops can be seen on video.
Make the price of the fines high enough and you at least discourage the practice. I would even go a step further – If you flop a certain number of times, you get hit with a one game ban (similar to how 16 technical fouls during and 82 game season leads to a 1 game ban).
Are any of these solutions perfect? No, but they’re better than not trying to do anything about the problem.