Haters Gonna Hate The NFC West
12.17.10After the San Francisco 49ers were pummeled by the San Diego Chargers last night, they still only trail the leaders of their division by a single game. It just so happens that the Niners are still in the playoff hunt with a 9-5 FIVE AND NINE record, and this has a lot of people’s panties in a bunch.
People shouldn’t be so amazed that the NFC West could likely send a 7-9 team into the playoffs. What is amazing (to me) is how all of these people are crying foul over it. These are the rules that the league set up: Each NFC West team will have played each other twice, they’ll have played one game against every team in the NFC South (who have all been awesome, save Carolina, who will finally be getting rid of John Fox), and one game each against the teams of a competitive AFC West. That’s 14 common games, and if the NFL decides that they want to give a home game to the best team out of that format, they should do so.
If the NFL wanted to seed its postseason based on overall record, it needs to do one of two things: either balance the intraconference schedule so that every team plays each other once, or just get rid of divisions altogether, because they would mean nothing if the best team from that format wasn’t rewarded. The league set up a good system for postseason qualification and they should stick to it. The cries of “deserving” teams should only validate the strength of that system. This isn’t the BCS, ya know.


Perhaps you mean a 5-9 record…..OMG YOU ARE SUCH AN IDIOT! and all that other comment/blogger angst and what not…
That sentence makes no sense if I had really meant to say “9-5.” Appreciate the heads-up, guys.
I hate be the guy to do it, especially since I’m a niners fan, but they’re 5-9 not 9-5.
*sigh*
Get out of my head Biggs.
“Hey, come on now, those guys aren’t so bad and can’t control who they play. They deserve sending a team to the playoffs”
Love,
Big East Football Schools
@SJK I’m not saying that they deserve to go. I’m just saying that those other teams don’t have the credentials necessary to supplant them. Tampa Bay has a losing record in its division right now. Why should they go to the playoffs if they can’t beat the teams that make up nearly half of their schedule?
7-9 team in the play-offs? Deal with it.
That entire division could be blown up and the league wouldn’t skip a beat
As a Panthers season ticket holder that goddamn letter from Jerry Richardson had me fuming. I don’t want your fucking apology, I want my money back you selfish prick! But buying a seat license is like holding hands with fat Elvis.. it’s gonna get sticky sometimes.
Why should any team get a home game if they can’t even win their own division? And who cares really? Playing the NFC West champ is like getting another bye week.
@Punte
I was being tongue in cheek that the NFC West uses the same argument that the BE Football schools use.
If you ask me they both suck and shouldn’t get in the playoffs/BCS. But the system is set up the way it is.
Maybe the NFL could move more into Fantasy territory and set up their playoffs using a Victory Points system!
@SJK It was actually a pretty good argument. I think if Singletary started Vernon Davis on his fantasy team (because we all know he has one), then he would be as pissed off as we are.
@Punte
Not as pissed off as I am for drafting Shonn Greene in the 2nd round of a couple leagues.
The people who are all over this ‘sub .500 teams shouldn’t have home game/make playoffs’ nonsense are the same retards who were crying over the Pats missing out in 2008 despite their record.
The system is fair and it works. Not happy about a 12-4 wildcard team having to go on the road? Tough shit, they should have won their division if they’re so fucking good.
Yeatdog said it so good, I will simply swagjack.
The people who are all over this ‘sub .500 teams shouldn’t have home game/make playoffs’ nonsense are the same retards who were crying over the Pats missing out in 2008 despite their record.
The system is fair and it works. Not happy about a 12-4 wildcard team having to go on the road? Tough shit, they should have won their division if they’re so fucking good.