
Luckily, Keyboard Cat is on staff to play people off at a moment’s notice.
Kickers have always been an important part of football. In a matter of seconds, a kicker can completely change the fortunes of a game. The kicker has always been an eccentric breed, and while undoubtedly important to a team’s success, seems only be given recognition for bad plays.
Well a lot of the time that negative recognition is well earned. Sometimes, a kicker’s mistake is of historical proportions. And then, only then, is it worthy or our attention and scorn. Well, ladies and gentlemen, you’re in luck. You’ve got me to breakdown the greatest kicker fails in NFL history. Let’s get started, shall we?

Probably the one play in Super Bowl history that never gets the recognition it deserves. Here’s the situation. It’s Super Bowl VII. The Miami Dolphins lead the Washington Redskins 14-0 with 2:07 left in the game. Garo Yepremian, the little kicker from Cypress who coined the phrase “I keek touchdown” steps up to take a 42 yarder to seal the victory.
Unfortunately for Garo, what happened next was one the greatest fails in history. The kick is blocked by Redskins lineman Bill Brundige. Garo gets to the ball before everyone else and dives on it picks the ball up, and flails his arm to throw the ball. The ball is picked off by Redskins corner Mike Bass, and subsequently returned for a touchdown. Luckily for him, the Dolphins held on to win the game 14-7 to save a perfect season. Mercury Morris then began his career of being an obnoxious prick.
What can be said that hasn’t been said about Scott Norwood? There’s eight seconds left in Super Bowl XXV. The New York football Giants led the Buffalo Bills 20-19. Our boy Scott steps up to take a game winning 47 yard field goal. If he makes it, he’ll be a legend in Buffalo the likes of which has never been seen. Except he doesn’t. He drills the kick, has the distance, but the ball flies past the right goal post. The Gians celebrate, and Baby Duane Parcells is forced to save him temper tantrum for another day.

Curiously enough, video of the epic injury is no where to be found on the internet. Here's the gist of what happened. Bill Gramatica, a member of the Arizona Cardinals, nails a first half 42 yard field goal in a 2001 game against the Giants. Amazed, he starts jumping up and down like he just got his American citizenship. Suddenly, he goes down in agony, clutching his knee. He tore his ACL and had to miss the remainder of the season. Who stepped in to kick for the remainder of the game, you ask? None other than American hero Pat Tillman. What a badass.
Last season was a paticularly difficult time to be a Redskins fan. Jim Zorn was the coach, and Detroit’s 19 game winless streak ended against the politically incorrect Redskins. The team was 3-9 heading into a match up at home against the 12-0 Saints. After Drew Brees drove the Saints offense down the field to send the game into overtime, Shaun Suisham had the opportunity to give hope to a pathetic franchise. As you’ve probably already seen in the above video, he missed the kick, and New Orleans won the game, 33-30.
The Saints kicker, Garrett Hartley, kicked the overtime game winner, an act he would repeat in the NFC Championship game. He would also take the Saints’ onside kickoff to start the second half of the Super Bowl later that season. The Saints were also smart enough to kick the ball directly to the biscuit-dough-hands of Hank Baskett, a crucial play in their Super Bowl victory.
Any famous kicking fails I missed? Mention them in the comments.


You forgot to include Gary Anderson on the ’98 Vikings. He made it through the entire regular season without missing a single field goal or extra point, and then missed a chip shot would-be game winner against the Falcons that would have sent one of the best teams in NFL history to the Super Bowl.
What about Tom Dempsey’s 63 yard game winner(and long time NFL record)back in 1970 for the Saints. He was born without any toes on his kicking foot. Freak!
How about Nate Kaeding going 0-3 last year in the playoffs vs the Jets? Even Shayne Graham missing 2 the week before was a large fail. Or anything Mike Vanderjagt did post 2005?
O.K., I’m an idiot that needs to read better. Famous kicker fails. Did I mention I’m an idiot. This site really needs an “edit comment” button.
see: Mike Vanderjagt, career of
//punches wall
It was 1984, and the Dolphins had once again reached the AFC Championships. They were a surefire favorite to go on to the Super Bowl and bring another World Championship. Snap to Dan Marino, who held (with laces out, mind you) but failure fell on Ray Finkle that day. I think he’s a post-op tranny cop now.
John Kasay kicks the ball out of bounds late in the 4th in Superbowl 38, giving the Pats the ball on their 40 needing only a fg to win the game. Thank you very much Mr. Kasay.
Ray Finkle missing the winning kick in Super Bowl XVII. Although you may have omitted him since some people believe it was Marino’s fault on the hold.
Damn, I got beat by a minute.
I echo the nasty nate kaeding sentiment. Holy lord how does butters choke that badly?
You forgot the Cowboys’ Raphael Septian and his game changing handling of children.
Lin Elliott. It’s pretty bad when two of the six sentences written about you on your Wikipedia page — [en.wikipedia.org] — are in regards to your epic fail.
see: Shane Graham, career of
//i hate gingers
Two words: Lin Elliott
The saints score a 4 lateral td against jacksonville with no time left but john carney misses the extra point and they lose by one
Holy shit do you guys need a copy editor.
What, no college kickers? What about the series of FSU kickers who couldn’t make a field goal to save their lives to beat Miami in the late 80s/early 90s?
Someone named “Just and Idea” is concerned about editing?
how about the wind-blown, missed field goal that led to NATHAN VASHER setting NFL record for 108 yard runback for TD
Actually, it was punter Thomas Morstead, and not kicker Garrett Hartley, who executed the onsides kick in this year’s Super Bowl — the one where the New Orleans Saints (and not the Atlanta Falcons — high five!!) won the Lombardi Trophy.
The laces were in! THEY WERE IN!!!
Can’t we just re title kickers “White guys too shitty to play soccer?”